百U挑战百万U
4 Following
1 Followers
3 Liked
0 Shared
See original
Take a bold guess, will it break 0.1 today?
Quoted content has been removed
See original
How could you wake someone who is pretending to be asleep? It's pitiful and sad! In dreams, there is everything! They are unwilling to wake up.
The Pi Coin Scam Dream, it's time to wake up!
Pi Network, the only coin that you mine while your mom scrolls through short videos. Years have passed, you mechanically click the lightning button, fantasizing about 'global large-scale adoption' just around the corner. But what’s the reality? Where’s your money? Where’s your sports car? Where’s the exchange listing?
The Ultimate Scam of Pi Coin
🔹 'Coming soon!' This line has been fooling people since the last era.
🔹 'KYC is in progress!' Almost certified for three generations, but where's the coin?
🔹 'Building the ecosystem!' You can't even buy a hamburger, so what practicality are we talking about?
Wake up, the truth about Pi Coin
🔥 If it was truly valuable, it would have been trading freely by now!
🔥 If it has a future, it wouldn’t need to beg exchanges for listings everywhere!
🔥 If it’s a revolution, why does it still rely on recruiting others to survive?
In the end, this isn't an investment, but a scam. The only reward is 'hope' — a dream that can never be fulfilled!
Pi Network, the only coin that you mine while your mom scrolls through short videos. Years have passed, you mechanically click the lightning button, fantasizing about 'global large-scale adoption' just around the corner. But what’s the reality? Where’s your money? Where’s your sports car? Where’s the exchange listing?
The Ultimate Scam of Pi Coin
🔹 'Coming soon!' This line has been fooling people since the last era.
🔹 'KYC is in progress!' Almost certified for three generations, but where's the coin?
🔹 'Building the ecosystem!' You can't even buy a hamburger, so what practicality are we talking about?
Wake up, the truth about Pi Coin
🔥 If it was truly valuable, it would have been trading freely by now!
🔥 If it has a future, it wouldn’t need to beg exchanges for listings everywhere!
🔥 If it’s a revolution, why does it still rely on recruiting others to survive?
In the end, this isn't an investment, but a scam. The only reward is 'hope' — a dream that can never be fulfilled!
See original
Where is the face?
The PiFest shopping period is ongoing! Join now before the event ends on Friday, March 21. Experience the first PiFest after Open Network with the full support of external connectivity by shopping at your local stores and businesses that accept Pi. Discover such local businesses through the Map of Pi app on the Pi Browser. Currently over 100,000 registered sellers, including 51,000+ active sellers, are on Map of Pi waiting for you to discover and experience them! Share your Pi local shopping experience in the #PiFest channel on Fireside Forum.
Go to the Pi mining app home screen to participate and learn more!
Go to the Pi mining app home screen to participate and learn more!
See original
You are not black, I am black, farts are the trash of trash, I have been digging for 6 years, finally on the mainnet, but it has nothing to do with friends, nothing can be traded, it's just a scammer
Is this Pi coin? What garbage, I just want to criticize Pi coin
See original
Indeed Understand People
Technical dissection of Pi Coin: A traffic bubble disguised as 'inclusive finance'
The following analysis is from a technical perspective. If there are differing opinions, please refute from a technical perspective as well, thank you.
1. Consensus mechanism: The pseudo-decentralized 'Stellar Protocol' grafting technique
The Pi Network claims to use the Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP) and the Federated Byzantine Agreement (FBA), but in practice, it heavily relies on centralized servers.
Node threshold is a façade: The Pi mainnet nodes only require 'a phone online', with operational efficiency and security far below that of full nodes for Bitcoin/Ethereum, and actual computing power is concentrated in a few super nodes (only 0.1% of approximately 18 million KYC users running effective nodes).
1. Consensus mechanism: The pseudo-decentralized 'Stellar Protocol' grafting technique
The Pi Network claims to use the Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP) and the Federated Byzantine Agreement (FBA), but in practice, it heavily relies on centralized servers.
Node threshold is a façade: The Pi mainnet nodes only require 'a phone online', with operational efficiency and security far below that of full nodes for Bitcoin/Ethereum, and actual computing power is concentrated in a few super nodes (only 0.1% of approximately 18 million KYC users running effective nodes).
See original
What’s the use of just letting out a bunch of farts, this is pi
Analyzing PiChainMall and its Role in Pi Network’s Ecosystem
Discover PiChainMall: One of very few platforms driving real utility for Pi Network's ecosystem and the PI token.
The crypto space has produced several protocols over the past decade, with many focusing on offering real-world utilities for users. One such project focusing on this initiative is Pi Network, which has created several innovations to promote inclusivity for “Pioneers.”
The platform boasts of one of the largest communities, with over 60 million Pioneers mining its native PI coin using mobile phones. Ahead of its mainnet launch (Open Network), the core team has been developing its ecosystem with robust utilities to ensure users can utilize their mined PI in the real world. A standout contributor to this is PiChainMall, a merchant platform representing how Decentralized Applications (DApps) can add value to the blockchain.
In this article, we will explore Pi Network’s utilities and examine how PiChainMall enhances its ecosystem.
Pi Network’s Vision: An Ecosystem Driven By Utilities
Established by a team of Stanford Ph.D. graduates, the blockchain platform was launched to address three key challenges in the crypto space: accessibility, complexity, and lack of real-world use cases. Unlike traditional platforms that require energy-intensive mining rigs, Pi Network allows users to mine with their smartphones. This alone, contributed to its large userbase.
Of course, mining alone cannot sustain a token economy. The team realized this and worked towards creating utilities within its ecosystem, ensuring PI evolved from a mining token to a functional digital currency. The platform is home to several tools, applications, and services where Pioneers can use their assets meaningfully.
This initiative aligns with the creators’ vision of creating the "world’s most inclusive peer-to-peer economy," as they have shared repeatedly in their official channels. Utilities is the backbone of the PI ecosystem, enabling Pioneers to interact, developers to create DApps, and merchants to integrate Pi into their operations.
Speaking of utilities, below is a list of key use cases introduced by the core team:
Pi Wallet: A secure, user-friendly wallet for storing, sending, and receiving Pi tokens. The wallet simplifies cryptocurrency management for Web2-native users while maintaining Web3’s decentralized principles.
Pi Browser: Pi Browser is the gateway to the Pi ecosystem, allowing Pioneers to access DApps, explore the blockchain, and engage with community-driven projects.
Pi Developer Portal and SDK: Offers tools for developers to build on the Pi blockchain, fostering innovation through hackathons and collaborative projects. This has led to the integration of over 100 DApps into its ecosystem.
Know Your Customer (KYC) Solution: The KYC process ensures the network’s integrity by verifying real human users. This represents a critical step for securing the blockchain and enabling real-world transactions.
Social Profiles and Community Tools: Features like Fireside and Brainstorm enhance community engagement, allowing Pioneers to connect, collaborate, and propose ideas for ecosystem growth.
These utilities collectively lay the foundation for a decentralized ecosystem where Pi can transform from a speculative asset to a practical currency for everyday transactions. This emphasis on usability and scalability has positioned it as a promising platform in the Web3 space. However, the ecosystem’s success hinges on developing compelling use cases; PiChainMall comes in here.
PiChainMall: Powering Merchant Utilities in the Pi Ecosystem
PiChainMall, developed by PiChain Global, is one of the largest DApps in the Pi Network ecosystem. The ecommerce platform enables Pioneers to trade goods and services using Pi cryptocurrency, bridging the gap between digital assets and real-world usage. The protocol has a significant global presence, offering services in over 90 countries. PiChainMall exemplifies how merchant platforms can drive utility and adoption in a blockchain ecosystem.
How It Works
PiChainMall is a decentralized marketplace where users can create profiles, link their Pi Wallets, and engage in peer-to-peer transactions. The platform’s simplicity is one of its strengths, as users don’t need advanced technical knowledge or complete KYC verification to get started (though KYC will be required in the Pi ecosystem). Merchants can list physical goods, digital products, or services, while buyers can browse offerings and pay with Pi directly through the Pi Browser or mobile app.
The platform’s smart contract infrastructure ensures that transactions are recorded on the Pi blockchain, providing transparency and security.
Key Features and Use Cases
PiChainMall’s merchant platform introduces several practical use cases that enhance the Pi Network’s utility for PI holders:
Barter and Trading: Beyond traditional buying and selling, PiChainMall emphasizes community-driven barter systems, allowing Pioneers to exchange goods and services directly. This aligns with Pi’s peer-to-peer ethos and fosters economic collaboration.
Global Reach: With users from China to Nigeria, the platform transcends geographical boundaries, enabling international trade powered by Pi. This global accessibility represents Pi Network’s vision of an inclusive economy.
PCM Token Integration: PiChain Global introduced the PCM token, a utility token within its ecosystem. Users can earn PCM through daily mining, ecosystem activities, or DApp interactions, then use it to pay transaction fees (gas fees) or access premium services.
PCM Wallet: A non-custodial, keyless wallet designed for ease of use, The PCM, a non-custodial, keyless wallet designed for ease of use, serves as an entry point to PiChainMall and other PiChain Global DApps. It supports Pi currency and PCM, streamlining payments and withdrawals.
Synergy Between Pi Network and PiChainMall
The relationship between Pi Network and PiChainMall is symbiotic. Pi Network provides the foundational infrastructure, which includes blockchain, wallet, browser, and developer tools, while PiChainMall leverages these utilities to create a vibrant merchant ecosystem. This collaboration is evident in several ways:
Technical Integration: PiChainMall operates seamlessly within the Pi Browser and utilizes the Pi blockchain for transactions, showcasing the scalability and reliability of Pi Network’s technology.
Community Engagement: Both entities emphasize community involvement. Pi Network’s hackathons and developer programs encourage DApp creation, while PiChainMall rewards Pioneers for participation, strengthening the network’s user base.
Ecosystem Growth: PiChainMall’s success as a leading DApp validates Pi Network’s utilities platform, attracting more developers and merchants to build on Pi. This virtuous cycle accelerates the ecosystem’s expansion.
Conclusion
Pi Network’s utilities form the bedrock of an ambitious vision to make cryptocurrency accessible and useful for users. By providing tools like the Pi Wallet, Browser, and Developer Portal, they’ve created an environment where DApps like PiChainMall can flourish. PiChainMall, in turn, exemplifies the power of merchant platforms in driving real-world use cases, turning Pi into a currency that powers global trade, barter, and community collaboration.
Together, they are shaping a decentralized economy that empowers Pioneers worldwide. As Pi Network continues its development following the mainnet milestone, the synergy between its infrastructure and PiChainMall’s innovative merchant platform offers a glimpse into a future where blockchain technology seamlessly integrates into daily life. For Pioneers and observers alike, the ecosystem is one to watch as it continues to redefine the possibilities of Web3.
The crypto space has produced several protocols over the past decade, with many focusing on offering real-world utilities for users. One such project focusing on this initiative is Pi Network, which has created several innovations to promote inclusivity for “Pioneers.”
The platform boasts of one of the largest communities, with over 60 million Pioneers mining its native PI coin using mobile phones. Ahead of its mainnet launch (Open Network), the core team has been developing its ecosystem with robust utilities to ensure users can utilize their mined PI in the real world. A standout contributor to this is PiChainMall, a merchant platform representing how Decentralized Applications (DApps) can add value to the blockchain.
In this article, we will explore Pi Network’s utilities and examine how PiChainMall enhances its ecosystem.
Pi Network’s Vision: An Ecosystem Driven By Utilities
Established by a team of Stanford Ph.D. graduates, the blockchain platform was launched to address three key challenges in the crypto space: accessibility, complexity, and lack of real-world use cases. Unlike traditional platforms that require energy-intensive mining rigs, Pi Network allows users to mine with their smartphones. This alone, contributed to its large userbase.
Of course, mining alone cannot sustain a token economy. The team realized this and worked towards creating utilities within its ecosystem, ensuring PI evolved from a mining token to a functional digital currency. The platform is home to several tools, applications, and services where Pioneers can use their assets meaningfully.
This initiative aligns with the creators’ vision of creating the "world’s most inclusive peer-to-peer economy," as they have shared repeatedly in their official channels. Utilities is the backbone of the PI ecosystem, enabling Pioneers to interact, developers to create DApps, and merchants to integrate Pi into their operations.
Speaking of utilities, below is a list of key use cases introduced by the core team:
Pi Wallet: A secure, user-friendly wallet for storing, sending, and receiving Pi tokens. The wallet simplifies cryptocurrency management for Web2-native users while maintaining Web3’s decentralized principles.
Pi Browser: Pi Browser is the gateway to the Pi ecosystem, allowing Pioneers to access DApps, explore the blockchain, and engage with community-driven projects.
Pi Developer Portal and SDK: Offers tools for developers to build on the Pi blockchain, fostering innovation through hackathons and collaborative projects. This has led to the integration of over 100 DApps into its ecosystem.
Know Your Customer (KYC) Solution: The KYC process ensures the network’s integrity by verifying real human users. This represents a critical step for securing the blockchain and enabling real-world transactions.
Social Profiles and Community Tools: Features like Fireside and Brainstorm enhance community engagement, allowing Pioneers to connect, collaborate, and propose ideas for ecosystem growth.
These utilities collectively lay the foundation for a decentralized ecosystem where Pi can transform from a speculative asset to a practical currency for everyday transactions. This emphasis on usability and scalability has positioned it as a promising platform in the Web3 space. However, the ecosystem’s success hinges on developing compelling use cases; PiChainMall comes in here.
PiChainMall: Powering Merchant Utilities in the Pi Ecosystem
PiChainMall, developed by PiChain Global, is one of the largest DApps in the Pi Network ecosystem. The ecommerce platform enables Pioneers to trade goods and services using Pi cryptocurrency, bridging the gap between digital assets and real-world usage. The protocol has a significant global presence, offering services in over 90 countries. PiChainMall exemplifies how merchant platforms can drive utility and adoption in a blockchain ecosystem.
How It Works
PiChainMall is a decentralized marketplace where users can create profiles, link their Pi Wallets, and engage in peer-to-peer transactions. The platform’s simplicity is one of its strengths, as users don’t need advanced technical knowledge or complete KYC verification to get started (though KYC will be required in the Pi ecosystem). Merchants can list physical goods, digital products, or services, while buyers can browse offerings and pay with Pi directly through the Pi Browser or mobile app.
The platform’s smart contract infrastructure ensures that transactions are recorded on the Pi blockchain, providing transparency and security.
Key Features and Use Cases
PiChainMall’s merchant platform introduces several practical use cases that enhance the Pi Network’s utility for PI holders:
Barter and Trading: Beyond traditional buying and selling, PiChainMall emphasizes community-driven barter systems, allowing Pioneers to exchange goods and services directly. This aligns with Pi’s peer-to-peer ethos and fosters economic collaboration.
Global Reach: With users from China to Nigeria, the platform transcends geographical boundaries, enabling international trade powered by Pi. This global accessibility represents Pi Network’s vision of an inclusive economy.
PCM Token Integration: PiChain Global introduced the PCM token, a utility token within its ecosystem. Users can earn PCM through daily mining, ecosystem activities, or DApp interactions, then use it to pay transaction fees (gas fees) or access premium services.
PCM Wallet: A non-custodial, keyless wallet designed for ease of use, The PCM, a non-custodial, keyless wallet designed for ease of use, serves as an entry point to PiChainMall and other PiChain Global DApps. It supports Pi currency and PCM, streamlining payments and withdrawals.
Synergy Between Pi Network and PiChainMall
The relationship between Pi Network and PiChainMall is symbiotic. Pi Network provides the foundational infrastructure, which includes blockchain, wallet, browser, and developer tools, while PiChainMall leverages these utilities to create a vibrant merchant ecosystem. This collaboration is evident in several ways:
Technical Integration: PiChainMall operates seamlessly within the Pi Browser and utilizes the Pi blockchain for transactions, showcasing the scalability and reliability of Pi Network’s technology.
Community Engagement: Both entities emphasize community involvement. Pi Network’s hackathons and developer programs encourage DApp creation, while PiChainMall rewards Pioneers for participation, strengthening the network’s user base.
Ecosystem Growth: PiChainMall’s success as a leading DApp validates Pi Network’s utilities platform, attracting more developers and merchants to build on Pi. This virtuous cycle accelerates the ecosystem’s expansion.
Conclusion
Pi Network’s utilities form the bedrock of an ambitious vision to make cryptocurrency accessible and useful for users. By providing tools like the Pi Wallet, Browser, and Developer Portal, they’ve created an environment where DApps like PiChainMall can flourish. PiChainMall, in turn, exemplifies the power of merchant platforms in driving real-world use cases, turning Pi into a currency that powers global trade, barter, and community collaboration.
Together, they are shaping a decentralized economy that empowers Pioneers worldwide. As Pi Network continues its development following the mainnet milestone, the synergy between its infrastructure and PiChainMall’s innovative merchant platform offers a glimpse into a future where blockchain technology seamlessly integrates into daily life. For Pioneers and observers alike, the ecosystem is one to watch as it continues to redefine the possibilities of Web3.
See original
Every time I speak, it's just nonsense, I'm speechless.
Final Reminder: The Grace Period requires both KYC and Mainnet migration to be completed by 8:00am UTC on March 14, 2025, to avoid forfeiting most of your Pi other than Pi mined within the rolling window of the last 6 months before your Pi is migrated.
Learn more https://minepi.com/blog/grace-period-extension-mar-14/
Learn more https://minepi.com/blog/grace-period-extension-mar-14/
See original
The project party does not provide KYC and migration. What can the friends do? If they want to confiscate, just confiscate! Anyway, there is no intention.
Final Reminder: The Grace Period requires both KYC and Mainnet migration to be completed by 8:00am UTC on March 14, 2025, to avoid forfeiting most of your Pi other than Pi mined within the rolling window of the last 6 months before your Pi is migrated.
Learn more https://minepi.com/blog/grace-period-extension-mar-14/
Learn more https://minepi.com/blog/grace-period-extension-mar-14/
See original
Trash
Quoted content has been removed
See original
No, it will continue to be indefinitely postponed, this is the nature of the project party! Trash
#PI I will soon lose these 3415 coins, after 4 hours 😭😭😭
See original
It's already 0.7
#参与投票-PI该上线币安吗？
With the launch of Pi on the exchange, the Pi enthusiasts must be stunned. Previously, they were posting videos every day boasting that each Pi was worth hundreds of thousands. After painstakingly mining Pi for 6 years, the highest price at launch was below $4, and not to mention that it can't even be traded domestically. I wonder what the older generation who believed in Pi think now. The only exchange that can trade Pi domestically turns out to be only ZhiMa. As everyone knows, coins listed on ZhiMa generally lack liquidity, but this time, Pi being traded on ZhiMa has actually brought some liquidity to ZhiMa, directly putting ZhiMa in a tight spot. What does everyone think about this launch of Pi on the exchange?
With the launch of Pi on the exchange, the Pi enthusiasts must be stunned. Previously, they were posting videos every day boasting that each Pi was worth hundreds of thousands. After painstakingly mining Pi for 6 years, the highest price at launch was below $4, and not to mention that it can't even be traded domestically. I wonder what the older generation who believed in Pi think now. The only exchange that can trade Pi domestically turns out to be only ZhiMa. As everyone knows, coins listed on ZhiMa generally lack liquidity, but this time, Pi being traded on ZhiMa has actually brought some liquidity to ZhiMa, directly putting ZhiMa in a tight spot. What does everyone think about this launch of Pi on the exchange?
See original
Whether #参与投票-PI该上线币安吗？ is on or off has nothing to do with it, anyway, you won't get KYC, you won't get migration, and you won't be able to top up, it doesn't matter anymore.
See original
I encountered this last year too, 2000 RMB, it peaked at 770,000, I could only watch, couldn't exchange it, and after a week it went straight to zero.
Brothers, what should we do if we can't sell it?
See original
Trash is a scam
It seems that the Pi coins in everyone's hands can be sold immediately, but the problems mentioned above are very serious. So far, no one knows how to sell, to whom, and how much money can be sold.
To know the answer, we must know the answers to the following questions.
First, the test network needs KYC to transfer the coin to the main network. I believe everyone knows that KYC means real-name authentication. As the cryptocurrency with the highest market value today, Bitcoin has never required users to perform real-name authentication. Then Pi coins claim to make up for the excessive concentration of power and money in Bitcoin. The banner is very loud. To achieve this goal, we must follow the first principle of blockchain + - decentralization +. So in this process, where did the user KYC authentication data go?
Second, it has been three years since the launch of Pi coins. In these three years, various exchanges claiming to be able to trade Pi coins have emerged one after another, but they are all restricted by the fact that domestic users cannot transfer internally (internal transfers in the test network), but foreign users can. From this point, it can be basically judged that Pi is a completely centralized APP.
Third, the number of Pi users has exceeded 20 million, and more than half of them are zero-coin users. Even if Pi says that it will launch the mainnet within three months, there is still a long way to go from the mainnet to the exchange. How to ensure that the price of the currency will not fall below the issue price or even return to zero after listing on the exchange, and how to avoid scientists, these problems have not been solved.
Fourth, the issuance pricing. It is estimated that the total issuance of Pi coins will definitely exceed one billion. If you want to challenge Bitcoin, which is characterized by scarcity, then from what direction should you start to build Pi's value system.
To know the answer, we must know the answers to the following questions.
First, the test network needs KYC to transfer the coin to the main network. I believe everyone knows that KYC means real-name authentication. As the cryptocurrency with the highest market value today, Bitcoin has never required users to perform real-name authentication. Then Pi coins claim to make up for the excessive concentration of power and money in Bitcoin. The banner is very loud. To achieve this goal, we must follow the first principle of blockchain + - decentralization +. So in this process, where did the user KYC authentication data go?
Second, it has been three years since the launch of Pi coins. In these three years, various exchanges claiming to be able to trade Pi coins have emerged one after another, but they are all restricted by the fact that domestic users cannot transfer internally (internal transfers in the test network), but foreign users can. From this point, it can be basically judged that Pi is a completely centralized APP.
Third, the number of Pi users has exceeded 20 million, and more than half of them are zero-coin users. Even if Pi says that it will launch the mainnet within three months, there is still a long way to go from the mainnet to the exchange. How to ensure that the price of the currency will not fall below the issue price or even return to zero after listing on the exchange, and how to avoid scientists, these problems have not been solved.
Fourth, the issuance pricing. It is estimated that the total issuance of Pi coins will definitely exceed one billion. If you want to challenge Bitcoin, which is characterized by scarcity, then from what direction should you start to build Pi's value system.
See original
Pixiu coin, can only be bought, not sold
Brothers, what should we do if we can't sell it?
See original
Pixiu Coin
Brothers, what should we do if we can't sell it?
See original
Huobi's PI has been delisted
It’s not that Pi needs the cryptocurrency world, but that the cryptocurrency world needs Pi
The great Pi Network will surely lead a new era of cryptocurrency!
The history of cryptocurrency is full of ups and downs. However, the traditional currency circle is mired in speculation, with prices soaring and plummeting like a roller coaster, which makes ordinary people afraid to try. It is at this historical juncture that Pi Network came into being, like a red sun bursting out, illuminating the direction of cryptocurrency!
Current state of the cryptocurrency world: The old world will collapse
At present, the problems of the traditional currency circle are as serious as a terminal illness: speculation is rampant, bubbles are rampant, lack of application, and out of touch with the masses. Various digital currencies are like castles in the air, seemingly prosperous, but full of dangers. They are high above and cannot enter the homes of ordinary people. They can only be controlled by a few capital tycoons and become a tool for cutting leeks. If this situation does not change, it will be eliminated by history!
The history of cryptocurrency is full of ups and downs. However, the traditional currency circle is mired in speculation, with prices soaring and plummeting like a roller coaster, which makes ordinary people afraid to try. It is at this historical juncture that Pi Network came into being, like a red sun bursting out, illuminating the direction of cryptocurrency!
Current state of the cryptocurrency world: The old world will collapse
At present, the problems of the traditional currency circle are as serious as a terminal illness: speculation is rampant, bubbles are rampant, lack of application, and out of touch with the masses. Various digital currencies are like castles in the air, seemingly prosperous, but full of dangers. They are high above and cannot enter the homes of ordinary people. They can only be controlled by a few capital tycoons and become a tool for cutting leeks. If this situation does not change, it will be eliminated by history!
See original
Huobi's PI has been delisted
Quoted content has been removed
Login to explore more contents
Explore the latest crypto news
⚡️ Be a part of the latests discussions in crypto
💬 Interact with your favorite creators
👍 Enjoy content that interests you
Email / Phone number
Trending Topics
SaylorBTCPurchase
39M views
64,315 Discussing
Michael Saylor Posts Bitcoin Tracker, Hints at Potential BTC Purchase
Binance News
187 Likes
95.3k views
EUPrivacyCoinBan
750,496 views
10,606 Discussing
AppleCryptoUpdate
2.8M views
17,579 Discussing
