Certainly! Please see the simple and comprehensive Urdu translation of the report below:
---
Challenges of adopting Google's A2A and Anthropic's MCP protocols in Web3 – Summary of PANews report
According to PANews, adopting Google's A2A and Anthropic's MCP protocols as a communication standard for Web3 AI agents is not easy, as there are fundamental differences between the ecosystems of Web2 and Web3.
The first major challenge – Maturity of applications
A2A and MCP protocols gained popularity quickly in Web2 because they easily work with existing strong applications like GitHub. However, in Web3, AI agents are still in their early stages, and strong use cases like DeFAI or GameFAI do not exist, so these protocols cannot provide direct benefits.
For example, in Web2, a user can update code on GitHub through the MCP protocol without leaving their work. However, in Web3, transacting with local strategy along with on-chain data analysis becomes complex.
The second major challenge – Lack of basic infrastructure
It is essential for Web3 AI agents to provide a strong foundation, such as:
Unified Data Layer
Oracle Layer
Intent Execution Layer
Decentralized Consensus Layer
In Web2, A2A protocols connect agents easily via APIs, but in Web3 even a simple cross-DEX arbitrage is very difficult.
Example
If a user instructs the AI agent to "buy from Uniswap when the ETH price goes below $1600, and sell when the price increases," then:
The agent will need to read on-chain data in real-time
The gas fees will need to be calculated accurately
Slippage will need to be controlled
Protection against MEV attacks will need to be ensured
In Web2, this all happens easily through API calls, but the lack of infrastructure in Web3 makes this all a challenge.
Further issues – User intent and complex operations
In Web2, a user can easily book a cheap flight, but in Web3, if a user wants to transfer USDC to the Solana chain for liquidity mining, then:
The AI agent must understand the user's intent
Security, cost, and speed will need to be balanced
Atomic and cheap on-chain transactions will need to be completed
If this process is not secure, the concept of convenience disappears.
Summary
The value of A2A and MCP protocols is valid as it stands, but adopting them in Web3 without any modifications is unrealistic thinking. The lack of infrastructure in Web3 is evident, but this gap presents an opportunity for new developers to step forward and create new things.
---
If you want to simplify or shorten this for a video or presentation, I can prepare that as well.
