I will refute each "Your point"! I put them in quotes.

1. "Your stop – their entry"

A skilled scalper understands liquidity zones and uses them to their advantage, rather than placing obvious stops.

2. "Small time frame = fewer chances"

Scalpers do not compete with HFT, but work with the flow of orders and liquidity, where speed is not the main factor.

3. "Scalping is a game for robots"

Humans win due to intuition and adaptability, which algorithms lack.

4. "False signals and noise"

Experienced scalpers understand noise and work with it, rather than against it.

5. "A lot of effort, little profit"

With good risk management, commissions and spreads do not hinder making profits.

6. "No stable income"

Stability is not guaranteed by any style, but scalping offers more opportunities for profit.

7. "Scalpers think short-term"

They consider market structure and the overall trend, adapting faster than others.

8. "Better to hold positions longer"

Scalping reduces the risks of gaps and unexpected news.

9. "The mental game is against you"

Disciplined scalpers trade by algorithm, not by emotions.

10. "What to do instead?"

Scalping is not harmful, it just requires preparation, discipline, and experience.