Are you a Day Trader, Swing Trader, Position Trader, or Scalper? Each style has its own differentiators, and you should not make comparisons between them. Something simple, but that is sometimes forgotten: You should not compare distinct things. You need to find the operational method that best suits your profile. There is no right or wrong, there is no "most profitable method." Focus your energies and discover which method is most suitable for your profile.
