Why when deciding between 2 options do we only end up with a single option?

Because we believe that the power of choice makes us aware of how sophisticated we are. By choosing just one option, we limit ourselves when many times, almost always, we want not just 2 options but more. Or do we only drink 1 type of beer 🍺 or have 2 options for ice cream 🍨? Who doesn't have 3 or more 🍇 favorite fruits, or who doesn't go to several different bars, vacation spots, or restaurants 🍕, etc.

So the choice of multiple options is just hypocrisy because in reality we want not just 2 but all the options we like.