Thinking Through Fluctuations – Disposition Effect
If You Are Trading Futures, Then Go Through This
Main Takeaways
Thinking Through Fluctuations is our new blog series that explores common psychological mechanisms that affect traders’ decisions.
The disposition effect is the bias that drives traders to sell winners too early and cling to losing trades for too long, often at the expense of long-term performance.
Break the loop by setting clear rules, reviewing your overall portfolio strategy, and making decisions based on logic – not emotion.
You check your portfolio: one coin’s up, another’s down. You sell the winner, hold the loser – and feel oddly satisfied. But was that the right move? It’s a common behavioral pattern in trading, and one that may not always work out in your favor.
These moments inspired our new series, Thinking Through Fluctuations, where we zoom in on the subtle forces of trading psychology that skew and sway our decisions. By unpacking common cognitive mechanisms and biases, we aim to help you make clearer, more rational choices in the fast-paced world of crypto.
In this installment, we’ll explore the bias that could nudge traders to sell winners too early and hold onto losers for too long: the disposition effect.
The Psychology Behind Disposition Effect
The disposition effect is a cognitive bias that could lead investors to sell assets that have increased in value too early, while holding onto losing ones for too long. The instinct tells us to lock in gains and avoid realizing losses, even if that means making choices that aren’t financially sound.
Let’s say you have two tokens in your crypto portfolio. Token A has increased by 30 percent since you bought it, while Token B has dropped by 30 percent. Many investors would be inclined to sell Token A to lock in profits and hold onto Token B, hoping for a rebound, even if Token A has strong fundamentals and Token B is clearly underperforming.
The more rational approach would be to assess both tokens based on their future potential. However, the disposition effect leads us to focus on past performance instead, making decisions driven by the gains we’ve already made or the losses we’ve suffered. Instead of looking ahead, we end up holding on to the hope of recovering what we’ve lost, even when that might not be the most sensible choice.
On the surface, this behavior may seem irrational. But it starts to make sense when we zoom in on the psychology behind it. The disposition effect doesn’t exist in isolation – it’s shaped by two underlying forces: loss aversion and mental accounting.
Loss aversion refers to the tendency to experience the pain of losses more strongly than the pleasure of equivalent gains. This can make closing out a losing trade feel like failure – something many traders would rather avoid, even when holding on no longer makes sense.
Mental accounting involves treating money differently based on how we label or compartmentalize it. Traders may unconsciously sort their portfolios into "winners" and "losers," which can lead to emotional decision-making. Selling a winner feels like a win, while keeping a loser feels like holding out for redemption – even when the fundamentals suggest cutting losses would be wiser.
These two tendencies work together under the disposition effect. One encourages people to avoid the pain of losses; the other nudges them to treat gains and losses as separate emotional accounts. Combined, they create a reinforcing loop: traders feel rewarded for taking profits, but punished for accepting losses.
A Crypto Case Study
Imagine you’re holding two assets: a top-10 Token A and Token C, a memecoin. Token A has been performing well, backed by solid technical development and growing institutional interest. Token C, on the other hand, surged during a hype wave but has since crashed, with little indication of imminent recovery.
Even so, you might find yourself tempted to sell Token A “before it dips” while holding onto Token C, hoping it might eventually bounce back to your original buying price. This decision isn’t based on logic or analysis, but rather the discomfort of accepting a loss.
Here, the disposition effect has led you to make a counterproductive choice – cutting off potential gains from a strong performer and holding onto a weak one out of an emotional need to avoid realizing a loss, even when the market suggests it might be time to let go.
Breaking the Loop
The first step to managing the disposition effect is awareness. Once you start recognizing the emotional triggers behind your trading choices, you can take active steps to counter them.
One way is to set clear rules before you even enter a trade – like deciding your target profit and loss tolerance. These predefined levels help take emotion out of the equation when it’s time to act. Most platforms, including Binance, let you set stop-loss and take-profit orders in advance, so you’re not left scrambling in the heat of the moment.
It also helps to zoom out. Instead of obsessing over each individual trade, try evaluating how your entire portfolio is doing. Not every position needs to be a winner – what really matters is whether your overall strategy is holding up.
A trading journal can make a big difference too. Writing down why you entered a position and what would make you exit gives you something concrete to refer to – especially when impulsiveness or emotion threatens to override your original plan.
And when you're still conflicted, try asking yourself: “If I didn’t already own this asset, would I buy it today?” If the answer’s no, that might be your sign to move on.
Final Thoughts
The disposition effect might sound like just another technical term, but it reveals something deeply human. We don’t like being wrong – and we really don’t like losing money. But in trading, holding on to a poor decision just to avoid discomfort can turn a small mistake into a costly one.
Mindset matters. Let your winners run when the data supports them, and don’t hesitate to cut underperformers, even if it stings. The best traders know they won’t win every time. What sets them apart is strong risk management and the ability to stay level-headed in the face of uncertainty. Recognizing the disposition effect isn’t just about improving your trades, it’s about training yourself to think more clearly under pressure – a skill worth hodling!
Further Reading
Science Behind Crypto Misconceptions: Confirmation Bias
Is It a Bear or a Black Swan? Five Macroeconomic Events That Tested – and Proved – Crypto’s Resilience
Risk Management Strategies and Tools for Short Selling in Margin Trading
Disclaimer: This content is presented to you on an “as is” basis for general information and educational purposes only, without representation or warranty of any kind. It should not be construed as financial advice, nor is it intended to recommend the purchase of any specific product or service. Digital asset prices can be volatile. The value of your investment may go down or up and you may not get back the amount invested. You are solely responsible for your investment decisions and Binance is not liable for any losses you may incur. Not financial advice. For more information, see our Terms of Use and Risk Warning.