Peter Schiff, Chief Economist at Euro Pacific Capital and a persistent Bitcoin skeptic, has claimed that Bitcoin’s 21 million supply cap, frequently cited as evidence of the asset’s scarcity, is a “meaningless” metric.
The economist contended that if Bitcoin’s total supply were 21 billion instead of 21 million, with each BTC redenominated as 100,000 satoshis rather than 100 million, it would eliminate the perception of scarcity surrounding the digital asset.
That's my point exactly. Bitcoin's scarcity is about perception, not reality.
— Peter Schiff (@PeterSchiff) July 12, 2025
Peter Schiff’s Shocking Bitcoin ‘Meaningless’ Supply Theory Exposed
A Bitcoin advocate acknowledged Schiff’s point, agreeing that Bitcoin’s perceived scarcity is largely psychological.
The supporter drew an analogy to Ferrari’s limited production, noting that while only approximately 250,000 Ferraris have ever been manufactured, scarcity alone does not determine value.
Crypto investor Jeff Day countered this comparison, pointing out that Ferraris cannot function as currency and lack divisibility; you cannot own a fraction of a Ferrari.
Yes but Ferraris can't be used as money. Also, they are not divisible. In other words you can own a part of a Ferrari. Even at 115k Bitcoin can be bought by people with 100 dollars or even less. You can't do that with Ferraris.
— Jeff Day 
(@dayjeff) July 13, 2025
In contrast, even at Bitcoin’s current $120,000 price point, individuals with $100 or less can purchase portions of the cryptocurrency, unlike with luxury vehicles.
When a crypto investor highlighted the irony of Schiff’s criticism given Bitcoin’s surge while gold, his preferred asset class, remains stagnant, Schiff responded that gold has merely taken a “temporary pause.” He claimed silver is outperforming Bitcoin.
You always need an asset to back your story, don’t you Peter? First it was gold, then silver… soon it’ll be copper if it suits the narrative. Just admit Bitcoin keeps ruining your day 
— Mr. Crypto Degen (@subwayzarry1) July 12, 2025
Schiff’s Gold and Silver Bet Backfires As Bitcoin Crushes Record $123,000
On July 10, Schiff advised investors to sell portions of their Bitcoin holdings and purchase silver instead.
He argued that even if Bitcoin continues rising temporarily, silver should appreciate significantly more, and while Bitcoin faces potential crashes, silver’s downside appears limited.
Despite Bitcoin's new high today, had you followed the advice to sell Bitcoin and buy silver in yesterday's post, you would be better off. Plus, you would have taken on a lot less risk. https://t.co/6fhKHXOAru
— Peter Schiff (@PeterSchiff) July 11, 2025
However, Bitcoin ultimately outperformed silver during the measured period. While silver gained over 3.98% in the past seven days, reaching $39.04 per ounce, its highest level since September 2011, Bitcoin increased 12.2% over the same timeframe.
This follows Schiff’s April prediction during the Iran-Israel conflict tensions, when he reignited debates about Bitcoin’s future by asserting that “the financial crisis of 2025 will kill” the cryptocurrency.
This pessimistic forecast came just one month after he projected Bitcoin would fall to $65,000.
As with previous predictions, the cryptocurrency, originally created in response to the 2008 global financial crisis when major financial institutions collapsed due to risky lending practices and the housing market crash, has continued defying skeptics.
Since April’s low of $74,508, Bitcoin has gained over 60%, outperforming gold, silver, the S&P 500, and every major asset class globally, rendering Schiff’s predictions inaccurate once again.
BREAKING: Bitcoin surges to a record $123,000, now up +66% since the April 2025 low.
In just 7 days, Bitcoin has added +$20,000. https://t.co/725h5pHI2f pic.twitter.com/PjFj1d1rGw
— The Kobeissi Letter (@KobeissiLetter) July 14, 2025
Despite Bitcoin’s approximately 700% surge since the 2022 bear market and growing institutional and retail adoption, several prominent investors have dismissed it as a viable asset class.
In 2014, legendary investor Warren Buffett rejected Bitcoin at $600; it has since gained 19,400%.
Similarly, Berkshire Hathaway’s late Vice Chairman Charlie Munger famously called Bitcoin “rat poison,” among other criticisms.
Berkshire Hathaway CEO Charlie Munger calls Bitcoin a "rat poison" pic.twitter.com/gazQmwX32Q
— Crypto Jargon (@Crypto_Jargon) July 13, 2025
JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon has also criticized Bitcoin’s limited supply, suggesting that creator Satoshi Nakamoto would return when Bitcoin reaches 20 million in supply and erase all existing bitcoins.
However, former Binance CEO and Bitcoin advocate Changpeng Zhao has stated that even the most successful investors are not always correct about everything.
He encouraged people to purchase Bitcoin, suggesting that in several years, current prices will represent only a small fraction of its eventual value.
The post Peter Schiff Claims Bitcoin’s 21M Supply is ‘Meaningless’ – Says Satoshi Count is What Matters appeared first on Cryptonews.
